12:01:39 [Music] »AMY SHUMAN: Welcome, 12:02:35 everyone you just heard a song from the Sesame Street 50th anniversary celebration recording. 12:02:37 Phyllis May-Machunda's daughter chose this song 12:02:45 for us to hear as we begin this webinar. We are so glad 12:02:49 you are here. Hello, I'm Amy Shuman, current president of 12:02:51 the Fellows of the American Folklore Society. I'm a white 12:02:53 , Jewish, older woman with brown curly hair and glasses, 12:02:55 I'm wearing a red 12:02:57 shirt, a scarf, and silver jewelry. Behind me there is a 12:02:59 bookshelf 12:03:02 and a blooming Christmas cactus. I'm a Professor of 12:03:04 Folklore at 12:03:07 the Ohio State University where 12:03:12 I also teach disability studies. Welcome, everyone to 12:03:16 the third AFS Fellows Webinar. 12:03:18 The Fellows Executive Committee, Mary Hufford, 12:03:22 Robert Baron, and I, designed today's Webinar as 12:03:25 the first of a 3 part series on 12:03:31 Interrogating the Normal. The second Webinar in this series 12:03:33 on alternative medicine 12:03:36 and healing and will be held in November. Part three: 12:03:39 Folkloristic engagements with ecology will be held in spring 12:03:41 2023. 12:03:44 Each of our Webinars has been designed to build on and 12:03:46 create 12:03:51 intersections among folklorists and others. 12:03:55 Thus today's Webinar, Interrogating Normality: 12:04:00 Folkloristic Engagements with Disability, is co-sponsored by 12:04:03 the Society for Disability Studies, The Disability 12:04:07 Studies Graduate Student Association at 12:04:10 The Ohio State University, and the Office of the ADA 12:04:13 coordinator at OSU, in addition, 12:04:17 of course, to support from the American Folklore Society. 12:04:19 We are very grateful to Jessica 12:04:22 Turner and Meredith McGriff for 12:04:25 their enormous help. 12:04:30 We are also grateful to our ASL interpreters. 12:04:44 And to Christal Shew with Archive Captioning. You will 12:04:48 find captions link at the bottom of your screen. 12:04:50 Please put your questions for the participants in the Q and 12:04:52 A. 12:04:55 You are also welcome to use the chat function. 12:04:59 This Webinar will be recorded, and we'll make the recording 12:05:02 available through the AFS website as soon as possible. 12:05:11 Next Friday, a week from today , from 12-1:30, we'll hold 12:05:16 informal salon discussions about today's Webinar. 12:05:19 For each of our prior webinars , 12:05:22 we've held salons with about 10 people, and those have 12:05:25 turned out to be a wonderful opportunity for everyone to 12:05:27 share ideas. 12:05:30 Edited essays based on the first 12:05:33 two webinars, along with 12:05:37 summaries of the salon discussions, are now in the 12:05:39 process of being published. 12:05:48 Today's webinar will be published as a special issue 12:05:53 of the Journal of American Folklore. We will put the sign 12:05:57 up for the salons in the chat at the end of this webinar and 12:06:02 you will be able to sign up to participate also on the AFS 12:06:06 website. Some of the salons will be more general responses 12:06:11 to today's webinar and will also include a few special 12:06:17 topics. For example, we might have a salon on race 12:06:21 disability in folklore or folklore of children with 12:06:25 disability or the role of memoir and personal narrative 12:06:30 in disability. Or disability huge man rights policy in 12:06:34 folklore. Please use the chat to propose particular 12:06:37 interests and we will post the topic that is we decide on by 12:06:42 the end of this webinar. One of the salon's will have an 12:06:45 ASL interpreter and the registration form will give 12:06:49 you the opportunity to indicate that whether you want 12:06:53 to be in the salon with the interpreter and any other 12:06:56 access needs. We welcome your suggestions for making our 12:07:02 webinars more accessible. Today after each of the 12:07:06 presentations, I will provide a brief summary in plain 12:07:10 language. We will have three presentations and then the 12:07:14 presenters will be joined by three disabilities studies and 12:07:17 folklore scholars who will participate in a round table 12:07:23 discussion followed by questions you pose in the Q 12:07:29 and A. So, what does it mean to inter gait the normal? 12:07:33 People with disabilities often find they are designated as 12:07:38 not normal and disability study scholars and activist 12:07:41 have opened up a conversation about what counts as normal 12:07:47 behavior, practice, and bodies . In addition, to activism and 12:07:51 color ship about disability globally and nationally. 12:07:55 Disability studyings has identified both how different 12:07:59 bodies often refer today as body minds to critique the 12:08:03 ideas that bodies and minds are separate and how these 12:08:06 different body minds are represented and how 12:08:10 nondisabled people respond to what they perceive as 12:08:14 difference. The responses from nondisabled people have 12:08:20 included stigma, pity, and staring and also the seemingly 12:08:24 positive but harmful response of considering people who over 12:08:29 come their disabilities or who do very ordinary things to 12:08:34 be inspirational. Also significantly disability 12:08:37 studies criticized and often rejects what is call it had 12:08:42 medical model, the dominant narratives that govern's 12:08:45 people's lives by consigning them to diagnosis that does 12:08:50 not take into account how people actually live. 12:08:55 Disability plays a more implicit role in folkloristic 12:08:59 thinking and one of our goals today is to rethink some of 12:09:07 the implicit conceptions that drive folklore. For example, 12:09:12 Hymes con communicative competence a corner stone of 12:09:17 folklore studies contains implicit evaluations of what 12:09:23 counts as competence and who can perform compentently. 12:09:27 Folklorist bring several things to the table in 12:09:31 dismantling the normal including our interest in very 12:09:35 knack particular and every day practices and culture 12:09:39 that is operate on the dominant discourses and 12:09:44 practices. My work was profoundly by my teacher whose 12:09:49 book stigma the management of spoiled identity argues for 12:09:53 the social model of disability the idea that stigma does not 12:09:58 adhere in particular practices or bodies but rather is a 12:10:02 designation made by others who assign people and their 12:10:08 practices, ideas and bodies to the margins. Folklore is doing 12:10:13 either no graphic work in local communities can 12:10:16 contribute to our understandings of how 12:10:20 identities get spoiled and how people recuperate their status 12:10:24 within a community or create new communities of fellow 12:10:29 travellers who inter gait the normal. I think I was blocking 12:10:31 my 12:10:36 camera, sorry. Who inter gait the normal on their 12:10:40 own terms using their own genres of artistic performance 12:10:45 . These are some of the ideas we will consider today and now 12:10:55 we will turn to our presentations. Anand 12:11:51 Prahlad 12:11:53 »ANAND PRAHLAD: Thank you am 12:11:59 my to introduce myself visually I am black, I am 12:12:05 wearing a red shirt and I am wearing an rasta hat covering 12:12:14 my dread locks which is red, green and gold. Writing 12:12:18 outside the fairy tale voice that irreverent ruptures I 12:12:25 will begin with a story from 1991. I received a call from a 12:12:27 doctor at the 12:12:32 university hospital who had a patient who was a black woman 12:12:38 from the deep south who needed to have surgery, but she 12:12:46 refused the surgery because she believed that she had been 12:12:49 fixed. That a fixed had been placed on her. The doctor 12:12:56 asked me if I would sort of be a go between as far as the 12:13:00 communication between the patient and the medical staff 12:13:08 and if I would try to move the woman toward being more 12:13:10 receptive to the idea of 12:13:13 getting the 12:13:17 surgery. 12:13:24 In that moment I saw an exciting avenue for folklore. 12:13:29 But these impulses would have to wait. As far as the 12:13:32 expression don't change horse ins the middle of the screen 12:13:36 and I was already on the way to establish myself in 12:13:41 folklore studies to publish and get tenure 12:13:44 and gain the securities that would come with promotion and 12:13:49 rank. I never forgot that the doctor, that patient or the 12:13:52 possibilities that encounter suggested over the past 10 12:13:56 years, I have been able to move more in that direction. 12:14:01 Since publishing my memoir. I have noted primarily in 12:14:05 disability studies doing readings, workshops and 12:14:11 writing almost entirely in this vein and I have been able 12:14:15 to find a joy that sometimes alluded me in folklore studies 12:14:20 . This does not mean that I have abandoned folklore, quite 12:14:25 the contrary. In fact one of my current book projects 12:14:29 focuses on folklore in disability, health and 12:14:33 humanities. But in thinking about how to bridge the two 12:14:36 concentrations, disability studies and folklore. Several 12:14:43 issues come to my mind. One is the issue of voice, language 12:14:47 and creative write we focus a lot on issues of voice, 12:14:55 language, different registers of language, on awe dense and 12:15:03 author intent. And emotions and on the states of 12:15:07 consciousness of others be it characters or readers. On 12:15:12 their emotions and psychologies, on rhetorical 12:15:16 conventions and innovations. On the craft of what we do. 12:15:23 The art of it. On how we write positions us relative to well, 12:15:27 many things and so doing, we are infinitely concerned with 12:15:33 issues of race and gender for example with politics in 12:15:38 history, philosophy, the nature of producing text that 12:15:46 become commodified on the one hand but gait ways in the sub 12:15:53 PWHRAOEUPL. Emotional anchors, spiritual and intellectual 12:15:55 manna. 12:15:57 Revelations and e 12:16:01 PEUF anies in folklore studies by contrast we envisions our 12:16:04 missions in quite different terms the voices registers and 12:16:10 styles of our writing have been largely predetermined. We 12:16:13 are taught not to see ourselves has members of 12:16:18 communities often based on emotional needs, psychological 12:16:23 health and well being, and political identities but as 12:16:28 members of the academy. Members of an 12:16:33 academic discipline who studies such communities. But, 12:16:37 why is this difference so important? A second 12:16:40 issue is the marked did I have REPBS 12:16:44 between the general orientation of the feel of 12:16:48 folklore and fields such as disability studies that are 12:16:52 concerned with issues of disability, health and 12:16:55 medicine. In contrast to folklore studies disability 12:17:00 studies is rooted in political and social advocacy in what 12:17:04 has been refer today as identity politics. These are 12:17:08 core elements that attracted me personally to the field and 12:17:12 that he me to feel at home in it. But, to understand their 12:17:18 importance of this orientation , one has to appreciate first 12:17:23 the historical oppression and daily trauma of being a 12:17:27 disabled person in an ableist society. One must accept the 12:17:31 most heart felt understanding of this oppression and 12:17:34 willingness to publicly advocate for the rights of the 12:17:39 disabled is for many a major criteria in measuring how they 12:17:43 perceive and relate to other people, organizations and 12:17:45 academic 12:17:50 disciplines. In my own case, for example, I decided 12:17:54 that I had given enough or more than enough of my life 12:17:59 work that required mask and accommodating to ableist 12:18:04 expectations and norms and that didn't already have the 12:18:07 scholarly and creative frame works for directly addressing 12:18:12 the concerns of the disabled. Rather, I decided to put my 12:18:15 energy and time into projects and pursuit that is would help 12:18:20 to validate the experiences of disabled people. To empower 12:18:24 them in whatever small ways that I can. And to illuminate 12:18:28 some of their realities to others who are interest ed in 12:18:34 better understanding them and in being political and social 12:18:38 allies. Of course, being retired helps as I no longer 12:18:43 have any masters to serve. This brings me to a discussion 12:18:48 of my own memoir. The secret life of a black [word?] The 12:18:52 greatest break through in writing that memoir was to 12:18:56 findly cochlear away enough layers 12:19:04 clear away enough and a voice is not just a tone, it is an 12:19:08 attitude. The embodiment of experiences and the ways of 12:19:12 perceiving and processing the world around one. It is the 12:19:17 personal as well as the community vibe one carries 12:19:24 with one. It is the resonances of values just as a dance to 12:19:28 music is the residence innocence of rhythm, timing 12:19:33 and sound. Those who have read the memoir may have noticed it 12:19:38 flip it is script that instead of being a folklore professor, 12:19:42 scholar writing about a disabled subject or object, 12:19:47 the memoir is the disabled subject offering critical 12:19:49 observations. 12:19:54 I have taken the nothing about us without us seriously and in 12:19:57 the memoir in subsequent writing I have chosen to 12:20:02 employ a narrative voice that is outside of convention. One 12:20:07 that center it is speaker's experience of disability while 12:20:12 platforms of academic discourse become more like 12:20:16 satellites rather than home planets as such the voice and 12:20:21 writing style represent a rupture, a dissonance in the 12:20:24 relationship to customary written traditions and instead 12:20:30 of critiquing disability, the work inter gaits proper and 12:20:36 academic discourses in which disabled representations are 12:20:40 found. My work is then envisioned as a representation 12:20:43 mode of validation and 12:20:48 empowerment as text that resinates with and speaks 12:20:51 specifically to those whose lives are centered in neuro 12:20:56 diverse and disabled universes . Some of the chapters are 12:21:00 specifically concerned with the 12:21:04 spaces within schools including elementary, high 12:21:07 school and various universities that I attended. 12:21:12 For example, the title of the chapter the white castle is 12:21:18 intended to suggest that the predominately white school 12:21:22 setting is for a black artist surreal. 12:21:25 Like being in a world 12:21:28 found in brother 12:21:34 Grimm's fairy tail. This is instead tended to hit on some 12:21:37 of the important life negotiations that came with 12:21:42 entering the academic profession and is a fairly 12:21:47 detailed black artist critique of academia. One way of 12:21:51 looking at the memoir is to consider the many personal 12:21:54 stories as a form of 12:21:58 ethonography. Although I may understand this is beyond the 12:22:03 boundaries of what might consider valid 12:22:08 ethnography. An early version of one of the chapters was 12:22:11 published years ago in 12:22:16 a JAF on creative 12:22:26 ethnography. When the memoir was introduction, none of the 12:22:29 folklorist none of them wrote what was the least bit 12:22:36 positive so none of it was used by the press. Relative to 12:22:39 disabilities, interrogating the normal is not a small 12:22:45 thing. To take it seriously how ableist perspectives and 12:22:49 understanding that normal really means privileged. That 12:22:53 it means having a certain kind of mind and body and carries 12:22:58 with it assumptions, attitudes and practices that are usually 12:23:02 so taken from granted that they are not even recognized. 12:23:05 That it means being 12:23:08 enTREFPed in ableist political and social systems that 12:23:15 marginalize the disabled. Normal needs being able to 12:23:23 talk, being able to see, being able to hear. Not being in 12:23:31 chronic pain. Not being publicly shamed, humiliated 12:23:35 bullied, made fun of, left out , not being stuck and out of 12:23:40 luck if the elevator breaks down. Not having to take meds 12:23:45 in order to think clearly. Being able to walk into a room 12:23:48 and not being overwhelmed by the brightness of the lights 12:23:53 or the humming of fans or the sense that others don't notice 12:24:00 . Not having uncriminalable melt downs. Not having 12:24:05 uncontrollable switches, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, 12:24:08 et cetera. In concluding I would like to pose a few 12:24:12 critical questions. Questions that individual 12:24:17 folklorist will have to decide upon for themselves and 12:24:20 questions that would be productive I believe for the 12:24:25 entire discipline to consider. One has to do with intent, 12:24:30 purpose, goals. It is the goal to make disabled people and 12:24:34 communities a more common topic of studies will these 12:24:40 studies be ultimately more concern window the issues that 12:24:43 folkloristics have historically been concerned 12:24:47 with than with issues of rising from the concerns of 12:24:54 disabled people themselves or is folkloristics interested in 12:24:59 exploring ways of which an acute awareness of 12:25:05 disabilities may reshape the field. Is 12:25:10 folkloristics as the public sector side of things have 12:25:12 been engage window 12:25:14 advocate I. For 12:25:18 disability rights are we 12:25:22 proposing to but new wine into old bottles or the break the 12:25:28 old bottles and get new ones and moving toward a greater 12:25:33 awareness of disabilities is folkloristic proposing to 12:25:38 embrace disability studies along with its core principles 12:25:43 is it proposing styles of writing that are outside of 12:25:50 the generally academic rhetorical conventions? Is it 12:25:54 proposing to include nonacademic readers or readers 12:25:58 in the other fields? About the purpose or goals of some 12:26:03 of its writing and other pro 12:26:07 SKWROBGTs to include for example assisting in 12:26:14 policy making or in enlightening medical practice 12:26:18 TPHERs. Ableist foundations have shaped its methodologies, 12:26:22 theorys and definitions? Will the current book that I 12:26:27 am working on which makes a case 12:26:30 for the SPWRAL role various form of TPG played in the 12:26:33 oppression of the disabled and in practices within the field 12:26:36 of medicine be 12:26:43 accepted by folklorist and folkloristics and it is 12:26:45 definitely create 12:26:49 I have writing without 12:26:51 footnotes who is 12:26:56 folkloristics for? Thank 12:27:14 you. »AMY SHUMAN: If you have 12:27:17 issues you would like to include in the salon 12:27:21 especially or questions you would like to consider today, 12:27:28 that you can post them in the Q and A. I'm going to offer a 12:27:34 brief summary in plain language. Plan language is 12:27:37 intended for people who 12:27:43 speak and listen without the complicated language that we 12:27:49 use as folklorist. This isn't intended to replace what 12:27:54 Prahlad did. This is to intended for those in the 12:28:00 audience that may be able to join us if I summarize in 12:28:02 simple 12:28:04 act PHRA asked us to think about the difference between 12:28:08 our personal experiences and how we think and write about 12:28:13 them as people who study things. When he was writing a 12:28:17 story about himself and publiced a book about it he 12:28:21 had to think about how to write differently. Not as a 12:28:26 person that studies disability and folklore. Finding his own 12:28:31 voice which is his own way of talking. Based 12:28:36 on his own experiences. In his book, he wrote about being in 12:28:41 school as a black person with autism and he says that when 12:28:46 we think about what is normal, we should also understand that 12:28:50 some people have privileges that is particular advantages 12:28:55 that we don't even see. What would happen if we paid 12:28:58 attention to 12:29:01 disability as 12:29:05 folklorist. How would this change what we do? Might we 12:29:14 become more involved in disability advocacy. Our 12:29:19 second speaker is Phyllis 12:29:25 May-Machunda heifer 12:29:29 essay on her experiences 12:29:35 as a parent for folklore research and describes how 12:29:41 responses to ableism have begin to for some parents of 12:29:47 children with disabilities in similar ways how racism has 12:29:53 forged coalitions across racial group boundaries. 12:29:55 Working at that time 12:30:01 intersection of race and 12:30:07 phyllis asks us conceptions of disability as a burden. As a 12:30:11 sin or a curse as contagious 12:30:18 and an inferior human experience. As our executive 12:30:23 committee put together this webinar, we realized that we 12:30:26 know several parents including myself who are parents of 12:30:32 children with disabilities. And we are so glad to have 12:30:36 phyllis here to help us identify these new 12:30:40 intersections between folklore and disability I will 12:30:43 turn it over to you. »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: I need 12:30:50 to share the screen, please. Thank 12:31:37 you. Thank you. It is a pleasure to be here and I am 12:31:39 still 12:31:44 processing what Prahlad offered us. I am 12:31:50 Phyllis I am an older African American woman with 12:31:58 »ss and curly hair. I am wearing a hot pink turtle NEC 12:32:05 and a hot pink patch work jacket with hot pink 12:32:08 earrings. 12:32:13 I live in the -- my paper is called live not guilty the 12:32:20 Nexus of disability and care giving. And African parental 12:32:23 care givers critical 12:32:28 observations as a folklorist. 12:32:33 I live in the nexus of disability and care giving. I 12:32:39 am one of the parents of a now adult daughter who is 12:32:47 partially and inconsistently SRERL. Neuro 12:32:49 diverse, and multiply and 12:32:50 developmentallyvarious. Neuro diverse, and multiply and 12:32:53 developmentally disabled and and this journey on this path 12:32:58 began in infancy and will be life long. I began writing 12:33:03 about disabilities because it is my lived parental 12:33:07 experience and because I saw little attention in folklore 12:33:13 scholarship to the examination of the world of people with 12:33:16 disability ins folklore 12:33:24 scholarship. And to the stories of their families and 12:33:27 care givers as part 12:33:35 of those worlds. In my article complex identifying identity 12:33:38 through disability folkloristic perspectives on 12:33:43 being a parent and experiencing illness and 12:33:46 disability through my 12:33:49 child, that is 12:33:53 Otero and 12:34:08 Martenez-Rivera in their book 12:34:12 theorizing the margins 12:34:15 I use it had lens of 12:34:24 ethnography to describe my 12:34:28 family's SKWRORPB if I with my daughter.journey with my 12:34:31 daughter. Experiences of disability 12:34:34 by other mothers. 12:34:42 Framing my discussion of those accounts with folklorist Sandy 12:34:48 Dolby's notion of self-help books I observed that these 12:34:54 are mostly grass roots efforts by parents to write rich 12:34:58 counter narratives about disabilities of their children 12:35:02 as they navigated the social systems they encountered to 12:35:05 support and meet the 12:35:08 needs of their children 12:35:13 . I added my story to this ample body of narratives, but 12:35:18 I also wanted to look at this work through a critical 12:35:24 folkloric lens and examine how my family's experience was 12:35:26 different from these 12:35:30 published stories. 12:35:35 SPHEU scholarly work before I encountered folklore studies 12:35:38 has been to seek and examine 12:35:44 absent narratives. Who row mains invisible in our world? 12:35:49 Whose stories aren't we hearing? So today, I want to 12:35:52 continue that work and I have 12:35:59 selected three ideas that I want to touch on in expanding 12:36:05 from the published article. First, I want to state that 12:36:10 disability is often more an than individual's embodied 12:36:15 experience. It can also be 12:36:19 social, relational 12:36:27 a [word?] Experience. An experience that is 12:36:31 intersubjective and even for some 12:36:36 [word?]. As we do 12:36:40 treatments on our children 12:36:45 dependeden the impairment and degree of involvement 12:36:49 disability can shape the entire family 12:36:53 trajectory in terms of opportunities, 12:36:58 experiences of the family such as, you know, where you can go 12:37:03 and what activities you can do together. How can you do 12:37:08 those activities? The resources and the options 12:37:14 available to you. And how, you as a family 12:37:20 are seen and treated. One example from our experience is 12:37:23 because of my daughter's 12:37:27 sensory integration dysfunction, my daughter was 12:37:31 unable to eat certain foods or go to 12:37:34 parties which her class 12:37:38 mates in crowded places like 12:37:46 Chucky Cheese or Space Aliens or some of the most popular 12:37:48 rest 12:37:54 RAUPTs it shapes how she and we as a family were 12:37:59 included in school and church activities while many places 12:38:06 had bland foods, we were fortunate that our daughter 12:38:12 has a fairly sophisticated pallet. We often eight at 12:38:16 smaller ethnic restaurants. It was important we had fun 12:38:22 experiences as a family, we consciously centered our 12:38:25 activities around where she could go and what 12:38:28 she could do. 12:38:31 As 12:38:37 Susan 12:38:41 Kelly notes parents experiences of impairment are 12:38:45 not direct experiences of impaired body self. However, 12:38:53 these mediated narratives of disability offer intimate and 12:38:58 partial disability gained in the journey with the child 12:39:05 through a disabling environment. As Prahlad noted. 12:39:09 They are generated out of a relationship with a child and 12:39:13 often are the only window we have into the experiences of 12:39:21 those who are nonverbal or partially verbal. 12:39:26 Some parents, often mothers can develop difficult REPB 12:39:31 ideality extended identities this is an idea I mentioned in 12:39:35 my article. These 12:39:42 parents [word?] Aspects of themselves with that of their 12:39:47 child. The parent's life paths becomes transformed in care 12:39:50 taking and advocacy from the 12:39:56 positionalty of their child. Kelly calls it a 12:40:00 coConstitution of parenting identity and the experience of 12:40:03 impairment and the 12:40:09 embodiment of the child. I believe this part particularly 12:40:13 happens with children who are partially or nonverbal and 12:40:20 those more intensely involved. Those with more intensely 12:40:24 involved levels of impairment where communication happen ins 12:40:31 that trusted relationship and embodied levels and even a 12:40:35 mind meld seems to occur in the communication require 12:40:43 today understand what cannot be spoken in mutual 12:40:59 ways. So the narrativeings of this population of children 12:41:04 and their care givings are absent. Who speaks for those 12:41:09 that are unable to speak verbally or with technology? 12:41:13 The second idea I wanted to 12:41:16 explore a little bit was 12:41:22 thatted notion of parental care giver. Sometimes you 12:41:26 might think that might be an 12:41:30 oxymoron. Well the notion of care giver seems to be 12:41:35 redundant when paired with parent. Care giving includes 12:41:37 several 12:41:40 responsibilities and accountability that goes 12:41:45 beyond that traditional parent . Care givers have 12:41:47 responsibility for intense identifying and amplifying the 12:41:52 voice of the child by interesting the interface and 12:41:57 advocate for the child's needs as the family encounters the 12:42:01 social institutions that are supposed to address those 12:42:04 needs and the slide 12:42:07 shows some of those 12:42:11 aspect it is navigating the medical, social 12:42:17 services, educational, institutions on behalf of 12:42:21 their child. I can give an example from our 12:42:26 experience just last week. I spent at least 12:42:33 8 to 10 hours trying to find out why my daughter was billed 12:42:36 $11,000 for some dental surgery for which I had filled 12:42:46 out the paper work, I turned in at least 15 forms, and I 12:42:52 talked to a couple agencies before that surgery. As a 12:42:56 result, it was supposed to preauthorized and covered by a 12:42:58 medical 12:43:01 assistance and after reaching several answering machines and 12:43:06 calling back several times I had to talk with about 10 12:43:10 different people most of them gate keepers at that time 12:43:14 county and state level before I found a helpful person and 12:43:19 in an additional two more calls before I found out the 12:43:26 charge had been miscoded at the hospital. And it will be 12:43:29 resubmitted but I wouldn't find out whether it is covered 12:43:33 for another three months. You know, what are the stories of 12:43:38 the labor of family care givers and their encounters 12:43:42 with these institutions imagine having to continuously 12:43:49 put so much effort forward for such routine things. Who has 12:43:54 that kind of 12:44:03 time? 12:44:06 The 12:44:11 third point is I think a consideration of 12:44:15 intersectionality is necessary to illuminate more visible 12:44:22 stories of disability. It is a theory based in African 12:44:27 American's women's thought that black feminist scholars 12:44:29 Kimberly 12:44:33 Crenshaw and 12:44:35 pa TREURB I can't 12:44:42 Hill-Collins are 12:44:48 credited with developing intersectional theory asserts 12:44:53 that people are systematically positioned at disadvantage or 12:44:57 advantage simultaneously by multiple systems of oppression 12:45:03 through markers of group identity and the meanings 12:45:09 placed on them. Their race, class, gender, sexual 12:45:13 orientation, religion, 12:45:19 nationalalty, and citizenship geographic location and other 12:45:24 identity markers are what are 12:45:31 used. Now, yes, folklore has a history of 12:45:37 recognizing that people work - - they work with have these 12:45:39 identities but 12:45:42 intersectionality goes further . Intersectionality 12:45:47 acknowledges these social identities are not merely 12:45:52 additive they are multiplicative. They are 12:45:58 complex. They are systemic. And mutually constituted by 12:46:00 the 12:46:08 systems of oppression. They operate in synergistic 12:46:10 compounding 12:46:15 dynamic, variable, and interconnected ways and the 12:46:23 reason they do that is in order to produce experiences 12:46:28 defined by differential access to and control of resources 12:46:30 and 12:46:37 opportunities. 12:46:41 Intersectionality asks about how power 12:46:45 differentials are created 12:46:50 and that's something the normative stances of folklore 12:46:52 has 12:46:55 tended to 12:47:00 ignore. I'm going to offer a couple of examples. 12:47:04 Significant number of care givers are from outside the 12:47:11 family. So who are they? In many cases, they are paid care 12:47:18 givers who are disproportionally BIPOC women. 12:47:24 That is black and indigenous and people of color women. 12:47:30 Often immigrant women with limited education who are paid 12:47:35 minimum wage often without benefits to do this life 12:47:40 sustaining and capacity enabling work. What are the 12:47:45 stories of paid care givers of people working with disability 12:47:48 and how do their social 12:47:52 positionalties impact their experiences of working with 12:47:55 children? How do these 12:47:59 positionalties shape their 12:48:06 relationships with children with disabilities and their 12:48:08 families. What new 12:48:12 understandings can we gain from 12:48:22 looking at them? And their 12:48:30 stories? A story that came to me a skilled librarian new 12:48:33 immigrant woman care giver told me when she worked 12:48:36 through an agency 12:48:41 with a child she was ordered around as a servant and was 12:48:44 treated without respect. Feeling she was treated less 12:48:48 than a white worker would be. She stated she appreciated 12:48:53 working with people that would value the quality of care she 12:48:55 provided their 12:48:59 child. The issue with not one only 12:49:08 of perceived class but also race and possibly gender in 12:49:13 this case. So this 12:49:18 power point shows a number of the systems that could 12:49:22 intersect and this sort of gives a picture of what 12:49:28 intersection looks like. It is over lapping, interlocking, 12:49:35 and they can be raised up or lower down in terms of 12:49:37 importance 12:49:42 depending on the case. A second example is where are 12:49:48 the stories of BIPOC children with disabilities and their 12:49:51 families most of the publish stories of children's 12:49:55 disabilities by parents are written 12:50:00 mostly by economically and socially privileged U.S. 12:50:04 Canadian, British and Australian white women. 12:50:08 Setting a normative view of the children's experiences 12:50:16 with disabilities those stories are raced white. 12:50:24 Chris Bell in Blackness in Disability have called for how 12:50:30 racism and ableism work together as 12:50:36 does disability and critical race theory and education a 12:50:39 book by 12:50:44 Conner 12:50:49 Ferri and 12:50:59 Amnama 12:51:03 even for children with the same diagnosis as white 12:51:09 children the experiences of BIPOC children and their 12:51:13 families are not necessarily the same merely based on their 12:51:16 access to resources and on tuneties which is what systems 12:51:22 of oppression are strictured to control. One clue is 12:51:24 offered be 12:51:32 I by this 2020 report by the California Health Report 12:51:38 in a state where practices are for conscious than many other 12:51:42 places. Many parents of children with special health 12:51:48 care needs regardless of race report struggling to receive 12:51:55 prompt diagnosis and access to adequate therapy and support 12:52:01 services. But for families of color, particularly those that 12:52:06 are black and Latinx the struggle is more acute. These 12:52:10 families grapple with bias attitude from medical service 12:52:13 and education providers 12:52:17 . Sometimes the bias is unconscious but the net result 12:52:23 is the same. Poorer care than what families typically 12:52:27 receive. Health systems don't often account for the 12:52:29 impact of 12:52:34 institutionalized racism on people as color such as higher 12:52:39 poverty rates, less access to jobs, less flexible and time 12:52:43 paid off to care for kids. Greater transportation 12:52:50 challenges and that lack of awareness can exacerbate the 12:52:55 inequities. Culture and language barriers can make it 12:52:58 hard for these parents to navigate California's system 12:53:01 for children with 12:53:07 disabilities and advocates of said. This is from a 2020 12:53:10 report in a place that works to 12:53:17 serve the needs of children. 12:53:20 In conclusion ableism is 12:53:26 a system of oppression -- ableism as a system of 12:53:29 oppression provides challenges and barriers but it doesn't 12:53:36 work alone. Ableism intersects with other systems of 12:53:40 oppression to provide [ coughing 12:53:49 [coughing] vastly different experiences and the care 12:53:53 givers of those children. A theory of intersectionality 12:53:58 will aKHRAOUPL TPHAEUT the 12:54:04 across the 12:54:07 ability spectrum and their care givers it will equip us 12:54:12 to make visible and tell more complete stories of children 12:54:15 across the spectrum of abilities and of the people 12:54:23 who support them with care. Folklorist can help to end the 12:54:30 invisibility and absence of these narratives and to 12:54:34 challenge assumptions. 12:54:39 That's the 12:54:44 end. »AMY SHUMAN: Thank you so 12:54:46 much 12:54:49 Phyllis. Another really 12:54:52 terrific presentation 12:54:56 and just in case anyone didn't hear my original explanation, 12:55:02 I am going to try what I think is 12:55:09 describing this in plain language and 12:57:13 I encourage you all to help me out. I haven't ever tried to 12:57:15 explain 12:58:19 intersectionality. »NORA GROSE: I am talking to 12:58:24 you from my apartment in north London when it is the first 12:58:29 sun any day we have had no quite some time. I am going to 12:58:32 speak today not from a personal prospective I am not 12:58:36 a person with disabilities myself although I have worked 12:58:42 on disability issues since late 1970's and I 12:58:47 work in a much more pride than theoretical frame and I am 12:58:53 going to use this kind invitation from you folks as a 12:58:55 way of 12:58:59 encouraging or trying to more folklorist to get involved on 12:59:04 issues of implied inclusion of people with disabilities in 12:59:07 global health and international development and 12:59:11 local issues of social justice . I think folklorist have a 12:59:18 lot of offer and so far, the have Ises of folklorist are 12:59:24 missing in an important dialogue. Increasingly 12:59:27 call upon expert ins and practitioner it is social 12:59:31 sciences humanities, law public health but folklore is 12:59:36 called upon to inform and improve interventions to make 12:59:39 a difference in the lives of people with disabilities. I 12:59:44 think this is a lack of inclusion that represents a 12:59:48 significant over site. Folklorist have a lot of 12:59:50 contribute. Folklore incorporates a wide range of 12:59:55 beliefs and practices that inform and shape how 12:59:59 individuals and respond to beam with disabilities and how 13:00:06 people with disability's themselves frame the 13:00:09 world around them. Global health and international 13:00:10 development effort TOGS address the concerns, needs 13:00:13 and rights of the over 1 billion people 15 percent of 13:00:19 the world's populations who live with a disability. 13:00:23 Disability is called the world 's biggest minority group. I 13:00:28 will argue this should be under taken from two direction 13:00:33 folklorist offering their expertise and insights to 13:00:38 global help and decision makers and just as importantly 13:00:41 training on folklore for 13:00:46 experiments and in global development I would also an 13:00:51 important components should be leadership by folklorist with 13:00:56 disabilities themselves. My own background I won't go into 13:01:01 in great depth I am the director now of the university 13:01:04 college London international center for disability research 13:01:09 it is one of the few research center in the world that 13:01:15 specialized in low and middle income countries I am 13:01:18 anthropologist and work with a 13:01:21 team of social scientist 13:01:32 s. And we work on disability and poverty, social justice, 13:01:38 infection diseases, access to things like equal rights 13:01:41 for education, PHROEPLT 13:01:46 voting rights for people with disabilities specially in very 13:01:48 poor communities and we work with a lot of organizations 13:01:56 from the UN system the WHO down through a lot of 13:01:58 nongovernment 13:02:01 organizations Save the Children groups like that 13:02:06 through disables people's organizations and grass roots 13:02:12 advocacy groups I am anthropologist with a solid 13:02:15 background in folklore and I have found in all the work I 13:02:18 have done over the many years that folklore has consistently 13:02:24 be a corner stone of much of what I do. How I frame 13:02:26 questions? How I organize projects, approach individuals 13:02:30 , communities and organizations large and small. 13:02:38 Why folklore in particular? In why is it so important? 13:02:40 Well, for one thing folklore is a body of knowledge, 13:02:44 beliefs and shared understanding that helps 13:02:48 unique groups of people together 13:02:51 range from the broadest myths and ledgened to the smallest 13:02:54 shared stories to commentaries and jokes if we don't know 13:02:59 where people are coming from, we don't know how to ask them 13:03:03 to change or ask them in those cases where there is strength 13:03:08 ins the community how to preserve some 13:03:10 of those TRAOEGTs that make a difference in lives of people 13:03:15 with disabilities. Folklore is used as a form through which 13:03:17 groups 13:03:17 process established information and take on board 13:03:23 new information. It is also how they define perceived 13:03:27 threats either internal or external and it is constantly 13:03:30 changing. Again, if we are monitoring the folklore and 13:03:32 understand where 13:03:36 people are coming from 13:03:39 , in the most remote community in a small African village or 13:03:43 a large urban area in south east Asia. If we understand 13:03:46 what is going on with what 13:03:50 people are telling each with folklore we are way ahead of 13:03:54 the game in trying to make a difference in people with 13:03:58 lives of disabilities. Disability by the way there is 13:04:05 lots of ways I won't go through the nuances 13:04:09 I imagine people tuned in are HRRTD familiar with that. It 13:04:12 is important to state in the little time I have disability 13:04:17 is universal to all cultures there has never been a human 13:04:23 society anywhere that doesn't have not just one number nut 13:04:28 but a number of people with a number of different types of 13:04:38 disabilities. 13:04:42 Disability in general -- actually the term disbill 13:04:46 itself is not used in many languages and many countries 13:04:49 don't have a term for disability they will say 13:04:54 people who are blind, people who are deaf. Like the 13:04:58 unfortunates or those that deserve our pity or something 13:05:02 or other groups in terms of a single specific group, there 13:05:05 is complexity even in the small scale society in how 13:05:09 disability is seen. And it is based often on a 13:05:12 number of different variables and I won't go into all of 13:05:18 them. It depends on how communities and cultures 13:05:22 perceive how a disability occurs what it means for the 13:05:24 individual O to have a disability or what it means 13:05:29 for a family member to have a -- family to have a disabled 13:05:34 member in their midst. Both positive and negative 13:05:37 approaches to disability. It is very important often with 13:05:40 speaking about disability in negative terms but in fact 13:05:43 there is a lot of positive. When you look cross culturely 13:05:47 and you are looking within your own communities when you 13:05:50 talk to people who are 13:05:54 disabled THOEPLSs and their families it is -- there is 13:05:59 great deal of strength and diversity and insights we can 13:06:03 learn from people with disabilities. We have to be 13:06:07 very careful to not assume just because you have a 13:06:10 disability your life is not a rich and full one. It is often 13:06:14 true you are denied access to many of the resources that 13:06:17 make life easier and many of the social support that is 13:06:21 should be there. But, it is really important to realize 13:06:27 that all disabilities are complex. It is also to 13:06:30 understand disability in any society, you need to 13:06:34 understand the folk lore around what is considered 13:06:37 appropriate for a person with a disability that they can do 13:06:44 for themselves. That they can do for others or to others. It 13:06:48 is based in large part on the expectations of what role 13:06:57 society anticipated it will play as adults. [Word?] And 13:07:00 prejudice did yous is common. Amy mentioned I did my 13:07:06 doctorate many years ago on the deaf community on 13:07:13 Martha's Vineyard there was a high rate of hereditary 13:07:17 deafness because of a recessive 13:07:27 gene. They adapted to learn a new sign language on a regular 13:07:29 basis 13:07:32 people who are deaf there, I think had much easier time of 13:07:34 it 13:07:39 because they were considered " normal". There is no such 13:07:43 thing as normal normal members of 13:07:45 the KPWHAOUPBty having said that the life of a deaf person 13:07:49 there may have been easy but if you were intellectually 13:07:53 disabled or had a mental health concern, your life was 13:07:56 not necessarily any easier than anybody else with those 13:08:01 types of disabilities on the mainland. It is not disability 13:08:05 or no disabilities type of disability and how community 13:08:08 interprets that. And it is equal access 13:08:13 to resources. Persons with disabilities have the same 13:08:17 right to education, employment , 13:08:22 social, cultural and their lives are much better. Because 13:08:27 my time the limited as well. I don't want to go into great 13:08:31 detail, but let me give you a few exacts of what my 13:08:34 colleagues over the last few 13:08:38 years have worked on as using folklore as a component to 13:08:42 address issues of people with disabilities and communities 13:08:44 most 13:08:47 of our work is in 13:08:50 Africa and south east Asia but it is true around the world. 13:08:55 We have worked on folk beliefs and practices towards people 13:09:00 with disability around HIV/ aids that put people with 13:09:06 disabilities at increased risk for acquiring Aids or lessons 13:09:09 their chance of getting support and medical care they 13:09:13 need. We have worked on access to water and sanitation. We 13:09:19 did a large project in Zambia and 13:09:23 Uganda where we compared access to 13:09:28 water and sanitation to poems, sanitation for people with 13:09:30 disabilities who were the belief is they shouldn't be 13:09:35 touching water sources and they had -- there were beliefs 13:09:38 around people with disabilities and work to 13:09:41 identify what the folklore was and then work with the 13:09:45 communities and village leaders chiefs local or 13:09:49 disability groups to change these attitudes. We worked 13:09:56 with -- we did an oral history and either nothing RA if I and 13:10:03 survey as people working as disabled street biggers in the 13:10:10 capitol of Ethopia. We asked them how they got there, what 13:10:14 their lives were like and how they saw their futures. A lot 13:10:18 of folk lore was involved. My favorite was a gentleman that 13:10:25 said my job is helping people I step on the mosque in the 13:10:28 morning and church in the morning and collect [word?] 13:10:33 And if they give me those they get into heaven quicker. You 13:10:38 talk to these people and they had a wonderful, diverse, rich 13:10:42 way of looking at their own lives and they interacted with 13:10:47 both the folklore and the culture in which they lived 13:10:51 and it helped us much more effectively work with -- we 13:10:56 get to work with the united nations labor organization to 13:10:58 improve employment 13:11:03 opportunities for people that working as disabled street 13:11:05 biggers. If I wasn't 13:11:09 coming from a strong folklore background I wouldn't ask 13:11:13 these questions. In summary, I believe what I am talking 13:11:17 about is basically inclusion of folklore and using folklore 13:11:23 as a tool in international development, global health is 13:11:26 a two way street an important component in efforts and there 13:11:31 should be leadership by folklorist who are themselves 13:11:34 disabled as well as folklorist who have family members that 13:11:39 are disabled. Really rich insights. And folklorist need 13:11:45 to be more pro active in enter offering their insights to 13:11:48 global health and international decision makers 13:11:52 and in training, we should be -- be providing training on 13:11:55 folklore for 13:12:00 experts and advocates in international development of 13:12:04 global health circles around disability and folklore. We 13:12:08 should be training them to understand what is folklore, 13:12:12 what can be changed. What can't be changed and how we 13:12:16 need to take into account traditional beliefs and 13:12:21 practices if we are going to have any sort of hope making 13:12:24 people rethink disability and having people with 13:12:29 disabilities themselves take the lead in asking people to 13:12:32 rethink. Again we are talking about the largest -- really 13:12:37 the world's largest minority. We are talking about a billion 13:12:39 people 13:12:41 world lied and I think folklore has a lot to say on 13:12:45 that. Finally, there is a lot of this could mesh with the 13:12:49 global disability rights movement which is been in 13:12:53 constraint over the past two decades and importantly new 13:12:56 legislation up to and including the UN convention on 13:13:00 the rights of persons with disability if you are working 13:13:05 with people with disabilities and don't know about this this 13:13:08 is an important piece of 13:13:13 HREPLG alligators it has been rad if Ied by 186 [word?] 191 13:13:16 countries and that doesn't having something on the books 13:13:19 as a piece of legislation doesn't always change things 13:13:24 on the ground in the community , but none the less, it is 13:13:27 important we speak to the bigger picture of what is 13:13:31 going on globally with people with disabilities. Again, I 13:13:36 think we have an enormous amount of say and I would just 13:13:41 encourage anyone who is interested please drop me a 13:13:43 line. 13:13:45 Get orthopedic TPHAOEUZed together. I am so old I can 13:13:48 remember being at the 13:13:52 first group meeting there were 8 people who set up the 13:13:58 society for disability studies in 1983 it was led by [name?] 13:14:06 And I remember at the time sitting there and Erve saying 13:14:10 there are not enough people out there. Now it has 13:14:13 flourished for many years it is a major society. I 13:14:16 encourage you all to be pro tack difficult folklore can do 13:14:20 a lot more than we sometimes think it can. Thank you for 13:14:25 your time and again, and thank you for the 13:14:29 previous two speakers it has been a priority ledge to 13:14:35 listen. Thanks guys. Saw saw thank you that was 13:14:40 terrific. And I want to mention we have in our 13:14:43 audience today both folklorist and people from disability 13:14:49 studies the society for disability studies meets at 13:14:52 Ohio state and it is going to be virtual this year you would 13:14:55 all be able to join us in that conference if you are 13:15:00 interested. And we are trying to bring together these 13:15:06 different discourse between folklore and disability 13:15:10 studies. Those of you in disability studies that the 13:15:16 American Folklore Society is a global society. And within 13:15:22 that society, we have a group called the fellows and this is 13:15:26 brought to you by that group that tries to think of new 13:15:29 ways of advancing or interactions between folklore 13:15:35 and other fields. Now, what I want to do is a brief 13:15:40 plain language summary of Nora 's talk and I thought I might 13:15:45 mention to my knowledge the people who need plain language 13:15:47 know the term advocacy and that's an interesting thing it 13:15:52 is one of the words I don't have to translate into plain 13:15:56 language. Even if they don't speak, I have heard people 13:16:01 spell it or say it in other ways. And that's fascinating 13:16:06 in itself. Although it is a complicated idea, they would 13:16:13 know that. So, Nora says that folklore could do more work to 13:16:17 help solve problems about disabilities and health all 13:16:21 over the world. We need to work on education and on the 13:16:23 fact that some people don't have enough money or other 13:16:29 things and we need to work with lots of organizations 13:16:32 that advocate for people with disabilities. Folklore helps 13:16:37 us to ask questions and decide what to do to help people. 13:16:40 Folklore understands how people work together. We need 13:16:43 to know where people are coming from. Folklore can help 13:16:48 us to understand what people know and what they don't know. 13:16:51 And also to understand different kinds of 13:16:55 disabilities. Every part of the world has people with 13:16:58 disabilities. People's cultures and the stories they 13:17:02 tell can be important for how they understand disability. 13:17:06 Sometimes they don't even use the word disability. They are 13:17:09 treated differently, people with disabilities are treated 13:17:12 differently in different parts of the world. Some groups have 13:17:16 good ideas about what it is like to have a disability and 13:17:19 live a good life and we can learn a lot from them people 13:17:23 in different parts 13:17:27 of the world have different thoughts about what a person 13:17:31 can and can't do when they grow up and we can help them 13:17:34 change some of those 13:17:37 ideas. So, that's my 13:17:44 limited summary in plain language. So, now our three 13:17:49 participants will be joined for a round table discussion 13:17:55 by one disability studies scholar and two folklorist. 13:17:57 Rebecca 13:18:01 Monteleone focuses on disability technology, and 13:18:04 global policy she is an assistant science and 13:18:09 technology at the University of 13:18:11 Toleto. 13:18:14 Andrea 13:18:19 Kitta is a profession SOR in the department of English and 13:18:27 Sara Cleto is cofounder of the school of folklore and the 13:18:32 fantastic. I will now invite everyone to be part of this 13:18:40 round table. Also introduce you to Robet Barron wearing a 13:18:47 blue shirt he is secretary of the American Folklore Society. 13:18:51 And they will also maybe be part of this discussion. 13:18:55 So, I guess we will start. We didn't agree on who would 13:18:58 start, but I think I 13:19:03 will start by asking 13:19:07 Nora, Prahlad and 13:19:12 Phyllis if there is anything you want to add before we move 13:19:15 forward. Comments on each other's papers or anything 13:19:20 that is occurring to you. Go ahead, Phyllis. 13:19:23 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: I appreciated all of these 13:19:28 presentations this morning. Nora you highlighted the issue 13:19:35 that disability is not treated in a stigmatized way in all 13:19:42 places and for me, that helps 13:19:46 connect with the idea of 13:19:51 in the United States disability connecting with 13:20:00 other systems of oppression. Classism and racism 13:20:05 are two of those systems. It stigmatized in the United 13:20:12 States by itself, but it also interlocks with these other 13:20:18 ones. It is not that this is the way disability 13:20:25 naturally is. It is that we have some values 13:20:31 that 13:20:36 disvalue people with 13:20:40 disabilities and 13:20:46 disvalue them even more if they are people of color. 13:20:48 »NORA GROSE: I agree. And 13:20:51 again, any young students out there looking for a thesis 13:20:57 topic, we really don't know a lot about disability in any 13:21:03 number of communities tribal groups, ethnic groups, we know 13:21:06 for example that some native American groups have very 13:21:10 different views on disabilities and much more 13:21:14 acceptable of disabilities on some types of disabilities. 13:21:18 Even saying in the United States, I think we need more 13:21:22 data out there. It has been -- there hasn't been a lot of 13:21:24 research on 13:21:31 this. It is true that in the U .S. and especially disability 13:21:33 is famed not only by individuals and communities 13:21:39 but as you highlighted, the resources out there and social 13:21:45 supports what government can do to help. The inclusive or 13:21:48 exclusive education opportunities for a child 13:21:54 transportation, all of that is really complex. We lack the 13:21:59 fine details and one thing that always suprises me. I 13:22:05 have done a lot of work in's Africa you get distinctly 13:22:07 different 13:22:10 aPROUFPs on disabilities from one tribal group to the next. 13:22:13 They are right next to each other.pproaches on 13:22:17 right next to each other. I have given up and say we need 13:22:19 more information. »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: Let 13:22:27 me just say, I am not talking about within cultural groups 13:22:34 as much as the United States main stream 13:22:41 and no matter what you do within your cultural group in 13:22:42 the United States. »NORA GROSE: Yeah. 13:22:46 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: The larger picture of the United 13:22:50 States. Main stream that 13:22:55 disvalues disability. »NORA GROSE: I really grow 13:22:58 and think it is a really 13:23:05 important point. Yeah. »AMY SHUMAN: Do any of the 13:23:13 other panelist? I am going to turn to Andrea Kitta now 13:23:17 for your responses. »ANDREA K KITTA: As my visual 13:23:23 describe I am a white woman I have dark 13:23:30 curly wavy hair. This is an amazing panel and I thank all 13:23:35 of the participant so much. Being willing to hear these 13:23:38 stories and to listen to what we all have to say about this. 13:23:42 One of the things of course that we can't ignore is that 13:23:47 we are still in a pandemic despite what some people are 13:23:51 acting as if we are not. We are still in a pandemic and 13:23:55 how this has effected disability as well. So many 13:23:59 things were brought up by our amazing 13:24:06 speakers are effecting us right now including ideas like 13:24:11 Dr. Prahlad bought up about intent, purpose and goal. 13:24:15 That is so important right now as we transition to what I 13:24:20 hope will be a new world. I do not like the idea to return to 13:24:26 normal. I think that is a horrible idea. What we found 13:24:29 during the pandemic is getting better at things like this 13:24:33 like Zoom it was is more inclusive to so many more 13:24:38 people. And, I also as an instructor and someone with 13:24:42 ADD really benefitted from things like zoom conversations 13:24:45 that were recorded that I could then show my students 13:24:49 but I could also review later on so the things I may have 13:24:52 missed when I my attention where it maybe should have 13:24:56 been in that particular moment . I think we do need to 13:25:00 rethink and this is a great time to rethink and have this 13:25:03 discussion as we saw so many things that we were using that 13:25:06 were technologies that maybe based for people originally 13:25:10 with disabilities but the benefit of us all. I think 13:25:14 there is so many different things we saw during the 13:25:18 pandemic. So many things that were pointed out to us that 13:25:22 showed some of these technologies methodologies are 13:25:26 beneficial so everyone not just the disabled. And that is 13:25:29 so important in this particular moment and I think 13:25:32 we need to pause and think about that. But at the same 13:25:40 time, I also want to pause and respect [word?] Of how we 13:25:44 treated people with disabilities during this 13:25:50 pandemic. So many people melt their lives and convenience 13:25:56 was so much more important than so many other people's. 13:26:01 We lost so many people. And I think we need to take a pause 13:26:04 and think about that as well and what does that say about 13:26:07 us as a culture and society. I really hope -- I see everybody 13:26:12 here is very interested in working to dismantle some of 13:26:16 these issues but to also inquire about the roots of 13:26:20 things like the discipline of folklore. How are we based? 13:26:23 How is 13:26:28 ethnography against people with disabilities. How can we 13:26:33 improve that? I enjoy these were brought up by people. I 13:26:37 would like to thank all of the panelist for bringing up these 13:26:43 things and bringing them to the forefront and all of you 13:26:47 for coming and listening. I have about a billion questions 13:26:50 but I will let the 13:26:53 other people talk now. »AMY SHUMAN: Thank you Andrea 13:26:56 . And I want to remind everyone if you want to put 13:27:00 questions in the Q and A, we are going to pull those 13:27:03 together and try to answer some of them during the 13:27:07 webinar. I don't know if anyone wants to respond 13:27:11 immediately to Andrea? Otherwise, I am going to turn 13:27:14 to Rebecca 13:27:17 Monteleone and her comments. 13:27:21 »REBECCA MONTELEONE: I hello my pronouns are she her and as 13:27:25 a quick visual description I am a white woman with short 13:27:29 dark hair. Dark colored glasses and I am wearing a 13:27:33 scarf that is red and purple and white has a very loud 13:27:37 pattern on it. I want to thank you all for having me here 13:27:41 today. You know, I am coming as someone working entirely 13:27:46 outside of folklore. I work sort of at the intersection of 13:27:50 disability studies and science and technology studies and yet 13:27:54 , it I was scribbling notes the entire time I am seeing so 13:27:58 many resonances here that are worth drawing out a little bit 13:28:02 as part of our conversation. Primarily the thing I am 13:28:06 concern window and this is a concern for many disability 13:28:11 studies scholars are that he has issues of knowledge 13:28:14 politics whose knowledge counts and whose experience 13:28:18 gets interpreted as knowledge and whose doesn't. This alines 13:28:22 with questions that came up from today's panelist. Even at 13:28:27 the begin Amy mention third degree in the context in the 13:28:30 idea of competency and we think about it in the context 13:28:38 of creditability. Who get counts as credible. Who gets 13:28:43 to bare witness to their experiences and who does not. 13:28:48 In my work in cognitive ableism. That residence 13:28:56 and issues of competence and creditability and who counts 13:29:01 and who doesn't and who gets to tell their own story in the 13:29:05 way in which they tell it. How these are alining both in 13:29:10 issues of folklore and also in issues in my field in 13:29:13 technology development. And then the second piece that 13:29:20 really struck me that I wanted to call attention to is the 13:29:27 power of discourse in actually producing the material world. 13:29:31 Narratives that we have are embedded in the material 13:29:35 worlds we produce. Whether that is a public venue or 13:29:40 technology or something else. Thinking through that 13:29:44 complicated relationship between discourse and material 13:29:46 world, 13:29:52 how those narratives don't bare on the social and 13:29:57 political aPROEGSs disabled people face but the political 13:30:02 oppressions as well. Then shifting narrative can produce 13:30:04 oppressions as well. Then shifting narrative can produce 13:30:36 aoppressions disabled people face but the political a sort of radical reimagining of not just our society but our literal material world. And I think kind of pushing to 13:30:36 think about those connections a little bit more is certainlysomething that I think we need to engage with more in disability studies and science and technology studies but 13:30:36 could be an interesting connection here in folklore aswell. And then the third thing I wanted to think about beforeI sort of offer -- we can pass it on or have this as a 13:30:38 conversation. Is narratives of the future. The way ins which 13:30:43 we are invisioning futures and stories we still about the 13:30:48 future which are futures produced through technologies. 13:30:52 I am using my area of expertise these are future 13:30:56 visions that write disabled people out of them completely. 13:30:59 I think this idea of the narrative of the future brings 13:31:03 together all of these ideas at once. Who get it is authority 13:31:07 to tell those stories that future, how does that impact 13:31:10 the kinds of material realities we have now and what 13:31:16 sort of futures does that [ word?] On. What kind of 13:31:19 imaginative world are we foreclosing on because the 13:31:26 stories we tell about the future are discollude disabled 13:31:29 expertise. Those are the things running through my head 13:31:33 and I really appreciate the diversity of ideas that came 13:31:38 up here. Yeah. I I will pass it on for now and I am excite 13:31:40 today have a conversation. 13:31:45 »AMY SHUMAN: Nora it looks like you have a comment on 13:31:47 this. »NORA GROSE: She brought up 13:31:50 an important point narrative how people interpret 13:31:54 disabilities and what it is or what they owe to the greater 13:31:58 society in making sure people with disabilities are included 13:32:03 the narrative can include how people with disabilities 13:32:07 define their own life and can include I spent a lot of times 13:32:10 talking of ministers of health in various countries and how 13:32:15 they define disability or their narrative on disability 13:32:19 is critical important. 13:32:23 Becca's point about narrative is more than fact. Narrative 13:32:29 is the folklore cord that is helpful to use as a framing 13:32:31 mechanism. »AMY SHUMAN: That's a perfect 13:32:35 segue to Sara 13:32:40 Cleto. I didn't plan this. This happens to be perfect. Go 13:32:43 ahead Sara. »SARA CLETO: Hi everyone I am 13:32:48 Sara for a visual introduction I am a white woman with very 13:32:52 curly dark hair and I am currently wearing a shirt that 13:32:58 has a print of about a million wols on it. That could not 13:33:04 have been a more perfect segue into the kind of work I do. I 13:33:07 am very 13:33:09 literary 13:33:14 folklorist. I spend most of my time how folklore literature 13:33:18 over lap and how disability shows up in so many of our 13:33:22 narratives but often in ways people KPHRAOEPBTly don't 13:33:28 notice or take for TKPWRABTed. I have done a lot of work on 13:33:30 fairy 13:33:37 tales which are bursting with representations of disability. 13:33:41 That blew my mind most of us are familiar with fairy tales 13:33:48 and it is not something I had ever considered until 13:33:52 I started grad schools it is in every single one of the 13:33:56 major tales. And part of what I spent a lot of time thinking 13:34:02 and writing and teaching about is there are certain narrative 13:34:08 patterns we see again and again and again in fairy tales 13:34:11 with disability and some of them have been touched on by 13:34:16 previous speakers the most often narrative patted earns 13:34:19 we see are about over coming disability or curing 13:34:25 disability or enTPHREUBGTing disability on someone as a 13:34:29 punishment and there are other kinds of counter narratives 13:34:31 there are 13:34:34 examples of tales that don't do that. One 13:34:37 of my favorites 13:34:41 on fairy tales and the 13:34:47 Grimm's Fairy tales in particular where you disabled 13:34:51 animals working together to live their best life instead 13:34:55 of being defined in a negative way by their disabilities. 13:34:58 There are other possibilities out there. That is the -- 13:35:05 and I would love to see more and more other kinds of fairy 13:35:08 tales reimagining of 13:35:15 fairy tales which dove tails into what Becca was talking 13:35:17 about. 13:35:25 One of the things that really struck me listening to these 13:35:32 early presentations which were ail so amazing was the comment 13:35:35 from Dr. Prahlad about tone and attitude which also dove 13:35:39 tails into one of his questions about who 13:35:44 folkloristics is even for. A lot of the work I do now days 13:35:47 is sort of 13:35:52 academia adjacent. I don't work for a university. I have 13:35:56 my own business where I all I do is folklore and a lot of it 13:36:00 touches on disability. Because I am 13:36:06 outside or adjacent to the academy the way I talk about 13:36:11 these things is different. It has been really interesting 13:36:15 and a work in progress. What kinds of language do I choose? 13:36:19 How do I make this really 13:36:22 accessible to people who have maybe never encountered 13:36:26 folklore at all academically. People who have never 13:36:32 encountered disability academically and it ties into 13:36:35 what Dr. Prahlad was saying about attitude too and that is 13:36:39 such an important component and I am going to thinking 13:36:43 over that for a long time. My thoughts are not totally 13:36:47 formed there. I could go on. But I will stop now so 13:36:53 everyone else gets a time to talk again. Thank you so much 13:36:57 Amy and everyone else for putting together a wonderful 13:37:00 meeting and all of the 13:37:04 presenters who have offered such incredible food for 13:37:07 thought. »AMY SHUMAN: Thank you, Sara. 13:37:10 We are at a frontier moment here or I consider this 13:37:13 webinar to be a frontier moment where we are thinking 13:37:18 about the consequences for the folk lore. Prahlad you had 13:37:23 ideas about the ways we would have to reshape folklore if we 13:37:26 are going to engage with 13:37:32 disability and I think that it is a way to do 13:37:36 intersectionality, absolutely. And it is a way to consider 13:37:38 questions of social 13:37:42 justice. So, it is crossing all kinds of boundaries 13:37:45 especially the 13:37:52 academic and the boundary of academic and advocacy and as 13:37:55 several speakers have said disability studies already 13:37:59 does that. Disability studies was born out of the civil 13:38:04 rights movement really. It was the civil rights movement that 13:38:10 made it possible for disabled advocates to emerge following 13:38:16 that building on what they had learned from the civil rights 13:38:19 movement. We have to abandon that divide I will start by 13:38:23 saying if we are going to engage in disability studies. 13:38:28 I want to open it up now to the other speakers or other 13:38:32 ideas people have. Questions you want 13:38:35 to ask each 13:38:45 other? We can also open it to some of the questions that 13:38:51 have been asked by you in the Q app A. Maybe I will turn to 13:39:00 that and we have comments as well as questions. 13:39:03 »ANAND PRAHLAD: I have a question. 13:39:04 »AMY SHUMAN: Yes. »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: This 13:39:09 is for Phyllis. I really loved your presentation first. I 13:39:11 have been 13:39:14 thinking about this forever 13:39:22 I am wondering if there are any parent ins 13:39:24 TKPWROEUPs or communities you have mentioned who have 13:39:29 disabled children who are themselves 13:39:29 disabled? groups or communities you have mentioned 13:39:30 who have disabled children who are themselves disabled? And 13:39:33 how that might 13:39:40 complicate a lot of those issues even more that you 13:39:43 raised. On one of my -- and the reason I have thought 13:39:50 about it forever is I thought oh my God if I had disabled 13:39:54 children with my disabilities, how 13:40:00 would I manage? How would that work? So, just that 13:40:03 question. Do any of the parents you have run into 13:40:07 themselves have disabilities and how might that complicate 13:40:12 things for their 13:40:17 families? »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: In the 13:40:23 narratives that I have encountered I have not 13:40:31 encountered people who have disabilities who wrote about 13:40:32 them. »ANAND PRAHLAD: Uh-huh. 13:40:33 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: And 13:40:36 I think there is some real interesting 13:40:45 reasons for that. I think that the people who have had the, 13:40:50 the privilege of writing their 13:40:55 stories and experiences have been privileged themselves in 13:40:59 many ways. Those are the stories that have been 13:41:03 published. What I am 13:41:06 saying that 13:41:11 folklorist need to do is help get out the stories of maybe 13:41:17 people who have less access to privilege. I 13:41:23 mean, it is really hard -- being a parent of a child with 13:41:31 disabilities can be very time consuming, especially if 13:41:35 their level of 13:41:44 independence is where they need to be supported to be 13:41:48 independent. And some people have either multiple children 13:41:50 with 13:41:55 disabilities which I can't -- you 13:41:59 know, their stories and then there are people with 13:42:03 disabilities who are raising children with 13:42:07 disabilities. I 13:42:09 don't know 13:42:17 how they manage and some of them seem like they do not 13:42:23 have the full access to supports. Those 13:42:28 stories are not the ones that are published, but they are 13:42:35 ones we need to know. And, that's what -- I agree with 13:42:42 you, that's part of what we need to know. 13:42:44 »NORA GROSE: Could I add 13:42:48 something as well? She is raising a number of important 13:42:54 points. It also depends on the type of disability. 13:42:55 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: Absolutely. 13:42:58 »NORA GROSE: There are some that are inherited down 13:43:04 through families. People with different types of dwarfism or 13:43:09 have family heritages with they are familiar and 13:43:12 comfortable with that type of disability certainly the deaf 13:43:17 community there are families when the heritage of deafness. 13:43:22 In those cases, often the disability -- it is not to 13:43:26 say it is always easy, but having a child born with the 13:43:30 same type of disability you have is celebrated and is part 13:43:35 of the family tradition, community. 13:43:40 So, again, the issue is not just the family but how the 13:43:44 family is linked in and supported and part of the 13:43:49 broader community. I think it goes to say there hasn't been 13:43:53 a will the of work on any of this when it comes to ethnic 13:43:58 and minority communities, evenless. She is 13:44:04 emphasized a really important area that needs far more 13:44:05 research. »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: And 13:44:11 I think also your point that the hierarchy of disabilities, 13:44:19 there are some disabilities that are less totally 13:44:22 involving than other 13:44:23 disabilities. »NORA GROSE: Yes. 13:44:25 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: And the more totally involving 13:44:29 that disability is the more time consuming the support 13:44:37 work is for that. And, so, those stories don't get out 13:44:42 because there are other priorities and, you know, if 13:44:48 you are somebody that has to work two or three jobs to make 13:44:50 ends meet. »NORA GROSE: Uh-huh. 13:44:54 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: Where is your time to write 13:44:56 these stories 13:45:00 . »NORA GROSE: I sound in some 13:45:06 ethnic minority communities people who are -- families 13:45:11 with people with disabilities and people with disabilities 13:45:15 themselves your disability itself is not a priority they 13:45:21 are told. You go to the back of the line. I think that is 13:45:24 unTPOPBLG gnat and a 13:45:28 missed opportunity. 13:45:29 fortunate and a missed opportunity. 13:45:31 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: There are 13:45:36 also people who are sandwiched between generations. They 13:45:41 are caring for children with a disabilities and they have 13:45:45 their parent who is are becoming disabled. 13:45:48 »NORA GROSE: Right. »AMY SHUMAN: I was going to 13:45:54 say to tie this into material cultures and technologies in 13:45:57 Charm, 13:46:05 Ohio there is an inherited dwarfism among the Amish. They 13:46:10 all have the Fisk row of desks in the class rooms is for 13:46:14 little people. It is considered a part of that. 13:46:20 Also the buggys they drive there is a lot of adaptation 13:46:25 because there is an assumption of a large 13:46:28 population with this 13:46:33 TKRAR offism. Sayed the film 13:46:39 about a Palestinian community that has inherited deafness 13:46:46 and everyone there not only does everyone speak sign 13:46:53 language but their main industry in Al Sayed is the 13:47:01 repair of tractors and other trucks. It is very noosy and 13:47:05 they are aware the hearing people in the community don't 13:47:09 do as well because it is difficult to work with that 13:47:14 much noise. It is interesting then how that becomes a part 13:47:19 of how people are and you find an industry that works and the 13:47:23 film itself is about the question of whether they 13:47:28 should allow their children to get cochlear implants which is 13:47:31 another political 13:47:35 contra SRER I. There is some work oncontroversy. There is 13:47:40 some work on some of these things folklorist could make a 13:47:41 big impact. »REBECCA MONTELEONE: I wanted 13:47:45 to add a quick note about disabled parents. Connecting 13:47:52 us to the fact that disabled parents experience extreme 13:47:55 prejudice in the United States at least. There are statistics 13:48:01 saying 80 percent of people with intellectual disabilities 13:48:05 that become parents have their children remove from their 13:48:10 home. Another nuance is people who loose access to 13:48:13 that socially recognized identity at some point in 13:48:19 their life. These narratives might not be 13:48:22 recognized as parent 13:48:28 narratives because there is a denial in these social systems 13:48:28 . »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: 13:48:34 Building on that, there are a number of parents who loose 13:48:38 their children because they are believed to not be capable 13:48:41 of raising children because they have disability. 13:48:44 »NORA GROSE: Uh-huh. »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: And 13:48:49 so, there are legal issues and 13:48:56 foster care issues that intersect with disability 13:49:03 there as well. The notion of competence is an important one 13:49:12 for us to explore. And what results from people with 13:49:14 disabilities being 13:49:19 seen as incompetent and sort of 13:49:23 bridging off of that, 13:49:28 the notion of being 13:49:32 incompetent and 13:49:40 its connection with the vision of people of color being 13:49:45 imcompetent as well. It becomes 13:49:50 synergistic (sp?). »NORA GROSE: Also in some 13:49:56 countries, did some work out in Jordan in Egypt for example 13:50:00 where women who are disabled if they marry and have 13:50:04 children they live in extended families the comp P tendency 13:50:07 is not just the individual woman but the support network 13:50:12 around her. We don't take that into the states where 13:50:17 everybody is so individualistic. Most of the 13:50:23 world you lie in extended families and that is an 13:50:26 important component of families able to keep and 13:50:30 raise their kid ins a supportive house hold. 13:50:32 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: But if there are traditions where 13:50:34 those families are breaken up. 13:50:42 »NORA GROSE: Absolutely. Then it is the opposite. It is 13:50:47 also important we in the United States ask about the 13:50:53 parent and the mother and not about the communities in which 13:50:54 they live. »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: Yeah 13:50:55 . »NORA GROSE: We need a lot 13:50:59 more research out there for all of this. 13:51:00 »PHYLLIS MAY-MACHUNDA: There is an interesting 13:51:06 conversation going on in the chat about parents who 13:51:09 discover that they have disabilities when they find 13:51:12 out their child has 13:51:17 disabilities too. »ANDREA KITTA: This brings in 13:51:21 a very interesting part of disability that is taked about 13:51:26 which is sexuality and disability. I know Oliva is 13:51:28 here as well she worked with that in the past and that is 13:51:31 something we don't take about. We don't like to think of 13:51:35 people with disability as being sexually active. We don' 13:51:39 t like to inspite of the fact that is something we 13:51:42 absolutely should be 13:51:46 talking about and something that -- I believe this was 13:51:49 Olivia's work I am going off of here where she taked about 13:51:54 not only because it is a part of human life, but also 13:52:00 because there is a high rate of abuse. Including sexual 13:52:05 abuse and this is another part of this conversation that is 13:52:09 frequently just not discussed because of that [word?] Of 13:52:12 people of disability that is we don't want to talk about 13:52:16 them and sexuality. Any way, I definitely, say you should 13:52:21 look at Olivia's work she does a great job. If you could put 13:52:25 a link in the chat, that would be amazing. 13:52:29 »AMY SHUMAN: She has created a program called speak up stay 13:52:32 safe and she is a valuable resource for this for all of 13:52:37 this. Olivia please put something in the chat so 13:52:39 people can find you. »NORA GROSE: There is some 13:52:43 stuff here in the U.S. and in high income countries but 13:52:47 there is a fairly large literature and global 13:52:52 literature on sexual and reproductive health on people 13:52:54 with 13:52:56 disability and sexual reproductive health. Most of 13:53:02 it in the last five years everybody from the UNICEF to 13:53:07 the world health organization have a lot now on issues of 13:53:14 women and men and sexuality, family planning, and also 13:53:20 sexual abuse and physical abuse which unfortunately is 13:53:24 much higher in disabled populations. Mate be that some 13:53:27 I don't have you want to take a look at that literature and 13:53:32 bring the questions back home to higher income countries and 13:53:37 say we know about this but what do we know about it in 13:53:41 Ohio. Is the same discussion going on in Maine. There is 13:53:46 a lot out there we just don't know, but I think is very 13:53:47 importanted if we are going to have meaningfully discussions 13:53:49 about 13:53:54 a lot of this stuff. »AMY SHUMAN: I know Becca 13:54:00 works on this as well and is more of an expert than I am. I 13:54:04 got into the plain language because health depends on 13:54:08 plain language. If people are going to be advocates for 13:54:11 their own well being they have to be given the information in 13:54:17 plain language. I have begun translating things here at 13:54:19 Ohio State 13:54:23 University it was another hospital not in Ohio bit the 13:54:28 case came to us of a woman denied a kidney transplant who 13:54:33 had down syndrome because she wouldn't understand the postop 13:54:37 instructions. That's how I got involved in writing plain 13:54:41 language. It wasn't a choice of somebody else was going to 13:54:45 goat the kidney her brother was going to give her the 13:54:48 kidney they couldn't make the argument somebody else was 13:54:51 more deserving the only argument they could make is 13:54:54 she didn't understand the 13:54:57 postop 13:55:01 ration procedures when I translate it, I don't 13:55:05 necessarily understand the original. This is a 13:55:09 piece of the plain language is a piece of 13:55:14 health care as well. »ANAND PRAHLAD: I wanted to 13:55:18 mention since the idea of disability and sex came up. 13:55:22 There is a new book called 13:55:30 Sexy Like Us disability humor and sexuality. It is 13:55:38 Mildorodt I think it is coming out in August from the 13:55:42 University of Mississippi press. It is an exploration of 13:55:51 how disabled people online use humor as a way of dealing with 13:55:55 sexual issues. »AMY SHUMAN: Wonderful. 13:55:58 Wonderful. We are about out of time. Before anyone leaves I 13:56:04 wanted to mention the salon next week that I think we are 13:56:09 going to post the link now. We are not going to have separate 13:56:13 salons. We are just going to have one button for 13:56:17 registering for the salon and when you register, don't 13:56:21 register yet we haven't gotten that set up. Maybe the link to 13:56:25 register will be posted in a few minutes. There will be one 13:56:29 salon because the topics are so intersecting we decided not 13:56:33 to try to do separate topics. There will be small discussion 13:56:37 groups where you can continue this discussion with each 13:56:41 other. It just got posted in the chat. And we 13:56:45 need to know what your access needs are. So the most 13:56:50 important is we need to know if you would like an ASL 13:56:53 interpreter. We can have closed captioning. We can have 13:56:57 the automatic one for all of the groups but it would be 13:57:00 very helpful to know what your access needs are because that' 13:57:04 s the only thing that we will consider. Otherwise, we will 13:57:10 have you join the link and once everyone comes, we are 13:57:15 arbitrarily send you to your salons. If anyone is willing 13:57:18 to -- is interested because of this discussion if you would 13:57:20 like to be 13:57:23 a facilitator 13:57:29 e-mail me, we already have some people lined up to be 13:57:35 facilitates and note takes but we could always use more. Were 13:57:38 you going to say something 13:57:42 Mary? No. I thought you might . I hope you can all see this 13:57:46 link in the chat and also you don't need to record it now. 13:57:51 If you go to the American Folklore Society website, you 13:57:58 will find the link there to join the salon's next week. We 13:58:01 have found these are really important for creating 13:58:05 dialogue it is so difficult in a 13:58:10 webinar to each other. If we get you in groups of 10, you 13:58:15 will have a chance to really talk. The volume we want to 13:58:18 produce will include the presentations, the round table 13:58:22 and the summaries of the 13:58:25 aHROPBs towards creating a greater dialogue. In this 13:58:26 case, Isalons towards creating a greater dialogue. In this 13:58:30 case, I would say what comes out of this webinar can be 13:58:35 another catalyst for getting this whole field started. Some 13:58:39 of you asked about a network for further discussion. We 13:58:44 could create something a list serve. You have to think about 13:58:48 what everyone wants and we will learn more about that 13:58:53 next week at the salon. Did I miss something? Let's see - 13:59:00 - you got my e-mail dress. It is 13:59:10 Shuman dot one and we have other people's information. 13:59:14 You can't -- our participants because we are not in person 13:59:19 maybe you have seen in the chats the enormous amount of 13:59:23 gratitude that has been expressed toward you and our 13:59:26 presenters and round table 13:59:30 participants thank you so much we are so grateful and we hope 13:59:37 to see you next week at the round table noon to 1:30EST. 13:59:41 Maybe I will use my last minute to explain why. We have 13:59:46 participants in Europe and through India. Our Asian with 13:59:50 our south Asian participants they need today get special 13:59:54 permission if they lived in china to live here at all and 14:00:00 said it would be fine for us to end them a recording we 14:00:04 settled on a time people willing to get up early on the 14:00:07 west coast of 14:00:08 the KWRAOEUTS and some what late for our colleagues in 14:00:12 India and maybe there are a few people that did get on 14:00:16 from other parts of the world. That is how we settled on the 14:00:22 time. 12:00 to 1:30 next week. Look for the link and we look 14:00:26 forward to seeing 14:00:29 you. 14:00:35 Also our interpreters and our captioner. Really terrific 14:00:40 ASL interpretation so grateful to our 14:00:45 interpreters thank you. [Recording 14:00:48 stopped.]